Under the Influence: How The Silmarillion Restored Myth to Modern Fantasy

Modern fantasy loves to start at ground level. A farm boy raised in a sleepy village faces a problem that starts local and spirals outward. That pattern turns up all over because it’s easy for readers to follow and writers to scale.

The Silmarillion opens in an entirely different register.

Before any kingdoms rise or their heroes take up arms, The Silmarillion begins with creation through music. And instead of shady outsiders on a sinister errand, the first conflict comes through rebellion born of discord. The repercussions of that cosmic drama echo through every age that follows.

That choice alone sets J. R. R. Tolkien apart from nearly every writer who came after him.

Most subsequent fantasy authors adopt ascending world building, proceeding upward from small beginnings, Tolkien employs descending sub-creation that builds downward from first principles. Every event feels grounded in a rich and fully realized history. The result is a legendarium unmatched for its consistency in breadth and depth.

Readers can immediately feel the weight of that history, even when they cannot fully articulate why.

Read the full post on Substack!

Access it free for the first two weeks, then find it in the paid archive.