The Gatekeepers Can't Save You: How Indies Can Find Patrons and Thrive in the Ruins - Part 1: The Monoculture Died; No One Noticed

This is the first installment of a three-part series exploring how independent creators can find patrons and thrive while legacy institutions crumble. Over the course of this series, we will examine the collapse of 20th-century cultural gatekeeping, the illusions that keep creators waiting for nonexistent corpo sugar daddies, and practical ways to connect with readers, viewers, and listeners who actually want your work.

For most of the 20th century, cultural influence was tightly controlled. A handful of publishers, studios, and record labels decided what reached the public. Approval from these gatekeepers was treated as a mark of quality. To succeed, creators learned to navigate their demands. Originality was tolerated only when it could be safely packaged and sold. Audiences rarely questioned the bottleneck because there was little else to consume.

The collapse of that monoculture went largely unnoticed by the public. Streaming, social media, and digital distribution quietly eroded the old systems. By the early 2010s, a creator could upload a novel, release a film, or publish music without asking permission. Platforms like Patreon and Bandcamp made it possible to build a following from scratch. Fans no longer waited for a corporate imprimatur; they discovered and shared works themselves. The tastemaking monopoly had dissolved.

Yet the lesson did not fully reach creators. Many still waited for a call from New York or Hollywood. They believed that approval from a legacy institution was a prerequisite for legitimacy. The old mental model died slowly. Even when direct-to-fan platforms offered clear paths forward, the unspoken warning lingered: “Don’t move unless we say it’s safe.”

Meanwhile, independent creators were quietly proving the opposite. Entire careers were built without a single endorsement from a traditional publisher. Music projects funded by fans outperformed label-backed releases. Newpub authors sold in weeks what oldpub houses might have spent years attempting. Small teams of filmmakers released short films, web series, and features that captured audiences ignored by the multiplex.

The proof was there, yet most creators continued to wait …

Read the full post on Substack!

Access it free for the first two weeks, then find it in the paid archive.