One of the most common problems in new authors' drafts is easy to overlook, and it can undermine an otherwise promising novel.
Stop me if you’ve heard this one.
A man walks into a tavern. He spots a stranger sitting alone in the corner, approaches him, and starts asking questions about a missing artifact.
The stranger refuses to cooperate.
So our hero threatens him, starting a fight that ends with half the pub in ruins.
Is the scene above exciting? Yes. It’s got conflict, action, and plenty of room for colorful dialogue.
But it does leave one vital question unanswered:
Why did any of that action happen?
How did our hero know the stranger had information about the artifact? Why did he approach him instead of someone else? And what made him think threatening the man would produce the answers he wanted?
The author may have perfectly sensible answers.
Unfortunately, for the reader, those answers do not appear in the story.
Missing motivation
One of the most common problems I find while editing new authors is missing character motivation.
Sure, the characters perform actions. But the reader has little reason to understand why those particular actions are being taken.
Each action may even advance the plot. But without sufficient motivation, the characters come off as pieces being moved around a game board instead of causal agents.
Hint: Flimsy or absent motivation is usually the real reason beta readers call characters “unconvincing.”
Regardless, when readers stop believing in the characters, even the biggest plot turns hit like wet noodles.
Let’s dig into how we can spot and fix poor character motivation.
📚 First, a word on Combat Frame XSeed
What if you could read a military science fiction saga that captures the edge-of-your-seat space combat of Gundam and the ground-pounding grit of Battletech?
That’s the inspiration for my Combat Frame XSeed series.
If you like giant robots, political intrigue, and the larger-than-life drama of vintage mecha anime, Combat Frame XSeed was written for you!
Why authors miss flimsy motivation
Authors know more about their characters than readers do.
Sounds almost too simple, right?
But when you’ve put months into a story, you intimately understand what every major character wants, fears, and believes.
But readers only know what you’ve told them.
So your characters’ behavior can seem arbitrary if the story doesn’t include the relevant information.
That’s another reason to be highly selective about which beta reader feedback you take. Because more than one new author has removed an early scene which set up a character’s motives due to vague complaints about “pacing”.
(It’s almost never about pacing.)