Why Counterculture Authors Are Right to Black Pill on Publishing and Wrong About Its Future

Author Isaac Young recently laid out a bleak portrait of life as an counterculture novelist. From institutional indifference to algorithmic burial; from years of grinding to earning minimum wage and a polite shrug from audiences, the newpub path is cast as brutal.

The frustration is real. Writing a novel takes hundreds of solitary hours. Marketing demands hundreds more. And too often despite it all, first releases go unnoticed. Reviews trickle in on a geologic time scale. Meanwhile, bills come due regardless of artistic ambition.

No serious observer dismisses that hardship. But thankless toil isn’t the whole story.

Young’s tweet suggests that dissident writers face hopeless odds because publishers favor fashionable demographics, readers lack attention spans, and even success yields little financial stability. The implied conclusion hovers between resignation and warning: Without livable return on investment, great art will not reemerge.

But while there is some fire in that grim prognosis, it’s wrapped in the smoke of pessimism.

Read the full post on Substack!

Access it free for the first two weeks, then find it in the paid archive.