Why Your Characters All Sound the Same

Few editing problems sabotage a manuscript faster than a whole cast that sound like the same character.

New authors usually assume dialogue exists primarily to transfer information. One character asks a plot-related question. Another answers with the necessary details. The scene technically works, yet every speaker sounds interchangeable.

Quick test: Remove the dialogue tags. If the reader can’t tell who is talking, your books has the problem we’re about to solve.

Which it urgently needs, because nothing drains personality from a novel faster than samey dialogue.

Real people speak with individual cadence and vocabulary. One man speaks in clipped fragments while another rambles.

That means your scholar should tend to lecture. The soldier should front-load the point. A priest should address the moral implications. An arrogant noble rarely admits uncertainty. A frightened man qualifies every statement.

Many writers unintentionally give every character their own speaking habits. If you’ve read a book in which hardened warriors suddenly deliver polished monologues and teenagers speak like middle-aged academics, you’ve probably encountered this issue. In severe cases, entire casts develop the same sense of humor because the author can’t help bu impose his own verbal habits.

Read the full post on Substack!

Acess it free for the first two weeks, then find it in the paid archive.

My book Debt Reckoning launches soon on Kickstarter. Follow the prelaunch page. Early momentum in the first 24-48 hours makes a huge difference, so even just clicking “Notify me on launch” helps me and ensures you don’t miss out.